Tamko vs. CertainTeed vs. GAF Shingles: Which Is Right for Your Home?
7003114034 • February 6, 2026
Tamko vs. CertainTeed vs. GAF Shingles: Which Is Right for Your Home?
Choosing the right roofing shingles is one of the most important decisions homeowners
make during a roof replacement. At Willoughby Roofing & Sheet Metal, we work with
industry-leading manufacturers to ensure every homeowner gets the best combination of
durability, appearance, and warranty protection.
This article compares three of the most trusted asphalt shingle brands on the market today:
Tamko, CertainTeed, and GAF — including what makes each unique and how their warranties differ.
---
Tamko Shingles Overview
Tamko is known for offering dependable roofing products at a competitive price point.
Their Heritage® architectural shingles are a popular option for homeowners who want
solid performance without unnecessary extras.
Tamko shingles provide good wind resistance, classic curb appeal, and straightforward
warranty coverage that makes them a strong value-driven choice.
Tamko Warranty Highlights:
• Limited Lifetime Warranty for the original homeowner
• 10-year Full Start™ non-prorated coverage on materials and labor
• Wind coverage up to 110 mph (130 mph with enhanced installation)
• One-time transferable warranty within the first 5 years
Best For: Homeowners looking for reliable performance and strong value.
---
CertainTeed Shingles Overview
CertainTeed is considered a premium roofing manufacturer and is well-known for its
durability, design depth, and heavier shingle construction. Their Landmark® series is one
of the most widely respected architectural shingles in the industry.
These shingles often feature richer color blends and enhanced weather protection, making
them ideal for homeowners focused on long-term durability and aesthetics.
CertainTeed Warranty Highlights:
• Limited Lifetime Warranty for the original homeowner
• SureStart™ protection (typically 10 years) covering labor and materials
• Extended algae resistance warranties (often up to 25 years)
• Optional enhanced warranties through certified contractors
Best For: Homeowners who want premium durability, appearance, and long-term peace of
mind.
---
GAF Shingles Overview
GAF is the largest roofing manufacturer in North America and offers one of the most
extensive product and warranty lineups available. Their Timberline® shingles are among
the most installed in the U.S.
GAF stands out for its layered warranty options, allowing homeowners to choose basic or
premium protection depending on installation and contractor certification.
GAF Warranty Highlights:
• Limited Lifetime Warranty on qualifying shingles
• System Plus Warranty with extended non-prorated coverage
• Silver Pledge™ Warranty with workmanship protection
• Golden Pledge® Warranty with up to 25+ years of workmanship coverage
• Premium warranties available only through GAF Master Elite® Contractors
Best For: Homeowners who want the strongest overall warranty and system protection
available.
---
Final Thoughts
Every roofing brand has strengths, but the best choice depends on your budget, design
preferences, and warranty expectations. No matter which shingle you choose, professional
installation is critical to ensuring your warranty remains valid.
At Willoughby Roofing & Sheet Metal, we help homeowners select the best roofing system
for their needs and install it to the highest standards.
Contact us today to schedule a consultation and protect your home
Do you know the three signs that indicate the need for local roofing repair? Keep reading to discover the signs of a roof leak and when to call a professional.
Asking the right questions of local roofers can provide greater transparency and context, ensuring you make the best decision for your home and budget.
Replacing your commercial roof is an investment with numerous benefits. Learn why replacing your roof with a commercial roofing company is worth considering.
Share On: